This Pro Pick was released to clients on September 03, 2026 at 1:26PM ET.
img CFB

Mercyhurst at New Mexico State

September 5, 2026
img9:00 PM Eastern

I had the OVER on New Mexico State's opener last week against Florida State, and it missed by a couple of points in a loss, but the shape of that game is exactly why I'm going back to the well tonight. The Aggies' defense gave up 34 points to a quality opponent, confirming the same issue that showed up throughout a 4-8 season under Tony Sanchez, where the unit allowed nearly 28 points a game. Mercyhurst presents a far softer test than Florida State did. The program only recently moved up to the FCS level, and first-year head coach Thomas Sydeski, elevated after Ryan Riemedio's departure, is debuting against a jump in competition that many overmatched programs aren't ready for. Mercyhurst's own defense allowed nearly 25 points a game last season at a lower level than what it sees tonight, and New Mexico State's offense, modest as it's been, shouldn't have much trouble finding points against it. This is a defense with confirmed holes hosting a true road opener against a program still finding its footing at this level, and both factors point toward points piling up from both directions rather than a controlled night. The OVER is the play tonight, and this number looks light against two defenses I already have real questions about.

2 units on Game Total OVER 51.5 -108 (risk 2 to return 3.85)
Result:
WIN
Final
1
2
3
4
F
Mercyhurst Lakers
7
7
0
0
14
New Mexico State Aggies img
13
10
7
21
51
consensus consensus
odds odds
 
TAKE THE GUESSWORK OUT OF SPORTS BETTING

Get free CFB Picks

I pore over the data, injuries, news, and odds every morning.
You get the best bets delivered to your inbox.