Previous Matchups & Picks

April 9, 2026 6:45pm ET
@
Toronto Maple Leafs
Toronto Maple Leafs
#51
New York Islanders
New York Islanders
#52

Lines & Odds

+1.5 (-106)
Puckline
-1.5 (-114)
+243
Moneyline
-294
OVER 6.5 (-105)
Total
UNDER 6.5 (-115)

Maple Leafs vs. Islanders Betting Picks

Get Maple Leafs vs. Islanders betting picks, expert betting analysis, computer model picks, betting consensus data, matchup breakdowns, key betting angles, and the latest odds insights for today's Maple Leafs vs. Islanders game.

Public Consensus

Who was the public on? 67% of the public money was on New York Islanders to win on the moneyline. And, 66% of the bets were on the game to go OVER the total.

Computer Predictions

My computer prediction for this game was that New York would win by a score of 3.5 to 2.8 with New York winning on the moneyline, Toronto winning on the puckline and the game going UNDER the total.

Final Score

1
2
3
F
Toronto Maple Leafs
1
1
1
3
New York Islanders img
2
2
1
5

NHL Pro Pick Results

Here’s how my Pro Picks are performing.

NHLNHL All Picks last 17.1 years
Wins
Losses
Units
5,838
5,270
+210.63
NHLNHL Max Plays last 16.7 years
Wins
Losses
Units
1,852
1,557
+176.47
NHLNHL All Playoff Picks last 18.2 years
Wins
Losses
Units
832
686
+74.63
NHLNHL Between teams last 1 day
Wins
Losses
Units
1
0
+0.75
March 17, 2026 7:00pm ET
@
New York Islanders
New York Islanders
#11
Toronto Maple Leafs
Toronto Maple Leafs
#12

Lines & Odds

-1.5 (+167)
Puckline
+1.5 (-197)
-156
Moneyline
+133
OVER 6 (-110)
Total
UNDER 6 (-110)

Public Consensus

Who was the public on? 50% of the public money was on Toronto Maple Leafs to win on the moneyline. And, 50% of the bets were on the game to go UNDER the total.

Computer Predictions

My computer prediction for this game was that New York would win by a score of 3.4 to 2.7 with New York winning on the moneyline, Toronto winning on the puckline and the game going OVER the total.

Pro Picks

This Pro Pick was released to clients on March 17, 2026 at 10:39AM ET.
img NHL

New York at Toronto

March 17, 2026
img7:00 PM Eastern

The Islanders know how to win on the road, going 20-13-3 in their away games this season. New York won for the eighth time in 11 games with a 3-2 victory against the Flames this past Saturday. That was the Islanders' league-leading 25th one-goal victory this season. The Islanders have earned trust as they fight to stay in the playoff race. The Maple Leafs haven't. The Leafs are a near-hopeless 10 points out of the playoffs as the seventh-place team in the Atlantic Division. Toronto did upset Minnesota on the road two days ago, 4-2. That was just Toronto's second win in its last 11 games. The Leafs are minus team captain and prolific offensive threat Auston Matthews. He is out for the season with an MCL tear. Toronto is 29th defensively, giving up 3.4 goals a game. The Leafs have allowed three or more goals in 10 of their last 11 games. The Islanders cough up just 2.8 goals per game, fourth-best in the league. Take the Islanders. 

Final Score

1
2
3
F
New York Islanders img
2
1
0
3
Toronto Maple Leafs
0
1
0
1
January 3, 2026 7:00pm ET
@
Toronto Maple Leafs
Toronto Maple Leafs
#59
New York Islanders
New York Islanders
#60

Lines & Odds

-1.5 (+219)
Puckline
+1.5 (-269)
-114
Moneyline
-105
OVER 5.5 (-120)
Total
UNDER 5.5 (-105)

Public Consensus

Who was the public on? 57% of the public money was on Toronto Maple Leafs to win on the moneyline. And, 66% of the bets were on the game to go OVER the total.

Computer Predictions

My computer prediction for this game was that Toronto would win by a score of 3.1 to 3.1 with Toronto winning on the moneyline, New York winning on the puckline and the game going OVER the total.

Pro Picks

This Pro Pick was released to clients on January 03, 2026 at 12:16PM ET.
img NHL

Toronto at New York

January 3, 2026
img7:00 PM Eastern

Auston Matthews has picked up his game in a big way after a slump. That is bad news for the Islanders. Matthews has four goals and four assists during his last three games after scoring three goals in the Maple Leafs' 6-5 victory against the Jets two days ago. That was Toronto's fourth victory in its last five games, with the only loss coming to the Red Wings in overtime on the road during this span. Matthews has five goals in his previous six games against New York. The Maple Leafs are averaging five goals per game in their last five games. The Islanders don't have this kind of momentum. They are 3-5 in their previous eight games and just got blasted, 7-2, by the Mammoth at home two days ago. Worse for the Islanders is their leading scorer, Bo Horvat, who hobbled off the ice with a lower-body injury in that game and is out. Ilya Sorokin, the Islanders' top goalie, hasn't played since Dec. 19 and won't play here. Take the Maple Leafs.

Final Score

1
2
3
O
F
Toronto Maple Leafs
0
2
1
0
3
New York Islanders img
0
1
2
1
4
January 2, 2025 7:30pm ET
@
Toronto Maple Leafs
Toronto Maple Leafs
#9
New York Islanders
New York Islanders
#10

Lines & Odds

-1.5 (+217)
Puckline
+1.5 (-260)
-110
Moneyline
-109
OVER 6 (+100)
Total
UNDER 6 (-128)

Public Consensus

Who was the public on? 54% of the public money was on Toronto Maple Leafs to win on the moneyline.

Computer Predictions

My computer prediction for this game was that Toronto would win by a score of 4.2 to 1.9 with Toronto winning on the moneyline and on the puckline and the game going OVER the total.

Pro Picks

This Pro Pick was released to clients on January 02, 2025 at 12:32PM ET.
img NHL

Toronto at New York

January 2, 2025
img7:30 PM Eastern

Toronto beat the Islanders 3-1 on Tuesday when David Kampf, Steven Lorentz and John Tavares scored as Joseph Woll made 30 saves for the Maple Leafs, who have won five of eight. That game was at Toronto and the the Leafs have won eight of 10 in the second game of a home-and-home situation. Toronto also has won four of its past five road contests and New York is 2-8 playing with one day of rest. The Islanders have lost five of seven overall and they are 5-10 against Eastern Conference foes. Ilya Sorokin will start for New York and he is 11-12-4 this season. Woll is expected to get the call again for Toronto and he is 11-6-0 with a 2.48 goals-against average and a .913 save percentage. Take the Maple Leafs.

Final Score

1
2
3
F
Toronto Maple Leafs img
0
1
1
2
New York Islanders
0
1
0
1
December 31, 2024 1:00pm ET
@
New York Islanders
New York Islanders
#49
Toronto Maple Leafs
Toronto Maple Leafs
#50

Lines & Odds

+1.5 (-223)
Puckline
-1.5 (+185)
+111
Moneyline
-130
OVER 6 (-110)
Total
UNDER 6 (-110)

Public Consensus

Who was the public on? 79% of the public money was on Toronto Maple Leafs to win on the moneyline. And, 64% of the bets were on the game to go OVER the total.

Computer Predictions

My computer prediction for this game was that Toronto would win by a score of 3.9 to 2.3 with Toronto winning on the moneyline and on the puckline and the game going OVER the total.

Final Score

1
2
3
F
New York Islanders
0
1
0
1
Toronto Maple Leafs img
1
1
1
3

Get free NHL Picks

I pour over the data, injuries, news, and odds every morning. You get the best bets delivered to your inbox.