A showdown between the top two teams in the AL East. Toronto's grip on first place has been slipping, on an 8-8 run, as they play their fourth straight on the road. Starter Kevin Gausman has a 5.52 ERA against the Yankees this season, while the bullpen is 18th in ERA (4.15). The defense behind him is ranked 25th in fielding percentage. New York's offense is No. 1 in runs scored, third in on-base percentage, and No. 1 in slugging. Cam Schlittler (2.61 ERA) is holding batters to a .226 average, with the Yankees winning his last three starts. New York is on a 16-6 run despite playing the last seven on the road. Play New York.
This Pro Pick was released to clients on September 05, 2025 at 11:50AM ET.
Toronto at New York
September 5, 2025
1 unit on New York -126 (moneyline) (risk 1 to return 1.79)
Result:
LOSS
LOSS
TAKE THE GUESSWORK OUT OF SPORTS BETTING
Get free MLB Picks
I pore over the data, injuries, news, and odds every morning.
You get the best bets delivered to your inbox.